Treating Violence Against Sex Workers as a Hate Crime

I stumbled across RH Reality Check the other day and realized it is an important site that dares talk about issues that are rarely touched upon in the middle class feminist/lgbt “communities” like violence against sex workers. I’ve added a link to the Blog Roll.

From RH Reality Check: http://www.rhrealitycheck.org/blog/2010/12/16/draft-treating-violence-against-workershate-crime-liverpool

By Rosie Campbell and Shelly Stoops

December 16, 2010 – 6:40pm

Over the last decade sex work projects, the police and other agencies in Liverpool (United Kingdom) have been addressing violence against sex workers, encouraging reporting and taking crimes committed against sex workers seriously. In recent years Armistead Street, a sex work outreach and support project in Liverpool, has worked with Merseyside Police to continue to build on this legacy. This partnership has led to unprecedented increases in the number of street sex workers reporting crimes committed against them to the police, the number of active investigations of such crimes, and the numbers of people being charged, brought before the courts and convicted of crimes. Key to this success is the practice in Liverpool of treating crimes against sex workers as hate crime.

Liverpool is a city in the North West of England. The majority of women involved in street sex work in the city experience problematic drug use, with high levels (over 90 percent) of heroin and crack cocaine use. They also experience social exclusion including homelessness. Research in the city, and frontline project work, has for over a decade reported high levels of violence against street sex workers, 80 percent of them reporting they have experienced violence in the course of their work. These studies showed there was noticeable under-reporting of incidents to the police. The key reasons identified for not reporting were: sex workers believing they would not be taken seriously or would not be treated with respect by the police; a lack of trust in the police; poor previous experience with law enforcement; fear of revenge from attackers; fear of arrest for soliciting; anxiety about court cases and fear that involvement in sex work would become public.

Groundbreaking Move

Liverpool has had more than its share of tragic loss of lives amongst sex workers in the UK, with eight women who were involved in street sex work murdered since 1990, of which five cases remain unsolved. The most recent murder of Anne Marie Foy in September 2005 led to a debate in the city about how to manage street sex work, resulting in strong support to address violence against street-based sex workers. During the murder investigation, Merseyside Police acknowledged that relationships with agencies and sex workers were ad hoc, that there were difficulties contacting and maintaining contact with vital witnesses, and that there was a continued lack of trust in the police amongst sex workers.

In a groundbreaking move in late 2006 Merseyside Police agreed a policy that all crimes against sex workers be treated as hate crime. They were the first, and at the time of writing, the only force in the UK to do so. In this country, the hate crime model has been developed for dealing primarily with racially motivated and homophobic crime. In policing policy, if a reported crime is classified as a hate crime, it will receive an enhanced response with more attention and police resources being allocated to it. The hate crime approach implicitly recognises that violence against sex workers is shaped by discrimination and attitudes of hostility and prejudice.

Continue reading at:  http://www.rhrealitycheck.org/blog/2010/12/16/draft-treating-violence-against-workershate-crime-liverpool

3 Responses to “Treating Violence Against Sex Workers as a Hate Crime”

  1. quenyar Says:

    That’s a rather extreme example of the circle rounding – from love crime to hate crime.

  2. tinagrrl Says:

    “That’s a rather extreme example of the circle rounding – from love crime to hate crime.”

    WTF?

    Is that supposed to be amusing?

    Also, what in hell do you mean?

  3. quenyar Says:

    Sex – a biological function associated with emotional love. On a spectrum of good to bad, love is on the extreme of the good side. Hate is on the other extreme. We say that a spectrum is really not a line but a circle, where the extremes approach one another – love is life and hate is death, but life and death are parts of the same process. etc,…
    The love crime to hate crime was just a play on words. Personally I think violence against people should be a hate crime, with its ultimate expression being war.


Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: